Thursday, February 22, 2007

Letter to The Paper on quality, ca. 1988

Dear PAPER Gang: FEBRUARY xx, 1988

Well, since you've publicly raised the issue of new format for the PAPER, I will respond and try not to ruffle too many feathers....(impossible!)Please understand, this is a passionate critique of The PAPER, and not of the dedicated individuals whom I like and greatly admire. I know what it's like to produce The PAPER. Manic and insane dedication. You deserve the utmost of praise and respect.

In fact, I've kept my mouth shut for quite some time, though it hurt to see this very fine tabloid take such a serious nosedive. In order to critique and offer you suggestions, I'll look at what's already transpired. You are probably already aware of the problems.

Forgive the format. Read this as a personal reaction to what has passed, and not a reflection of the PAPER'S future. Please "carefully weigh and evaluate" the observations behind my rant. I rant because I care for what The PAPER has stood for. I am very pleased with your goals and objectives and I wish you the best of luck because I believe in what The Paper has stood for in the past. Perhaps it's not too late.

OK. the straight stuff. The PAPER has been incredibly BORING and DULL for quite some time...since your move to Forestvilie? Or dare I say since you lost your editor (and graphic designer) Nick Valentine? Not only that, you've lost many of your best columnists. Remember Bob Jones's Keeping the Faith? And Barrio? I didn't always understand him, but at least he was interesting, if not inflammatory. I'm not sure the rapid turnover of mediocre columnists has been very healthy for the PAPER.

This is how I see the PAPER: there's the appetizer (news, opinion and journal columns), the dessert (review and calendar), but no entree. Something in the middle is missing. No meat. No potatoes! Your
features are non-existent. Biz Biz is fluff-n-stuff, and some of the new "columns" are less than relevant.

At least Michele Navarette and Simone Wilson are good solid writers. Though I enjoyed Michelle's feature on flowers (good, informative prose style), it wasn't a main feature story. There should be more
human interest and feature stories as well as investigative journalism. More NEWS!

Where I see a severe weakness is in the journalism. Unfortunately, with the advent of the word processor, writing quality has taken a nosedive. It's now easier than ever to write awfully! Who, why, what, when, where. Don't forget to "pyramid." No matter that the text is boring. It's written in the right formula! I don't see any journalism awards on the horizon, folks.

What happened to investigative reporting? Those awards were given back in the days when we had no computers. Only humans. I have nothing against computers, I'm using one to write this letter. I object to
complacency. You mentioned intelligent articles for intelligent readers. You're on the right track. Question is, who's going to write it? So far, not much has emerged from the native raw talent. I think things are improving.though. Summer's a comin!

A wise Chinese philosopher is credited with the saying, "a picture is worth a thousand words." Well, what happened to the quality "pix"? The difference in good quality is so obvious when you use photos by
non-staff, ie., Janet Zagoria, Cheryl Trendly & Simone Wilson. Photo "specking" is uninspired too. I miss Nick's innovative pop-out formats.

If I had to cite one issue as the worst offender for boring the audience to death, then whipping them with wet noodles after; I'd choose the computer issue or the home improvement issue. Brick bookcases with a photo to illustrate the article in case the reader didn't "get" it? This was a waste of Simone's talent. And an awful photo. Who 'specked" it? Many of this winter's "advertiser theme" issues were also in this league.

Remember when the merchants "wrote" those "puff-pieces" on their businesses? What was the editor thinking of? Gag me with a spoon! I want to commend the ad-man John McDonald at this point for selling so many ads, but they were so numerous, I couldn't find the news!

Though I am interested in computers, the quality of David Om's column is inconsistent and not in-depth enough to be informative. I cite the computer "virus" column. It's a case of where the subject got away
from the author and the editor didn't catch it. I don't have the article in front of me...

Xxxx
the "virus" etc. Then, at the close of the article, with a leap in logic (or data lost in transmission) he gave garbled information on how to protect computer from said virus. How about a more rounded computer column, ie., Apple Mac and IBM, not IBM IBM IBM?

I overheard Tom Richman telling a client the PAPER isn't a "throwaway," that people carefully read it and pass it on. Well, it ain't necessarily so anymore. It takes me less than 15 minutes to read
the paper, then I toss it. Was a time it took me more than a half an hour to read it and I didn't immediately throw it away. I'm afraid The PAPER has already joined the ranks of the "shopper" rags.

Maybe the speed in which I read The PAPER has nothing to do with quality journalism or aesthetics. I like to think The PAPER is a cut above the competition, but this too is an illusion. Layout is flabby and inconsistent. (Too much white space, illogical composition, crooked layout, mixed typeface/size on corrections, etc.). The worst layout that comes to mind was of my own article— the coverage of the
Mendo. Offshore Oil hearings in February.

Remember Nick's red-pencil critiques of The PAPER? It seems you lost your most valuable resource when Nick finally had enough of PAPER politics and left. After all, Nick WAS The PAPER! Months after his departure, you finally acknowledge his absence in an editorial. I won't comment on the internal irony of the statement, "We are aiming to provide the news....unflinching examination of local subjects."

It seems, when the editorial torch was passed along, aesthetics got left behind. The computer is partially at fault for the uninspired graphic presentation of The PAPER. So much is preprogrammed, thanks to
MacLayout cloned artistry and typography.

Is there a real artist in the house sensitive to graphic design and layout or are you all relying on the MacPagemaker/Laserwriter's facsimile of layout art? What happened to the "back to the drawing
board" approach when things didn't hang together?

Today it seems, newspapers everywhere have succumbed to mediocracy—like in the late Malvina Reynold's famous song, "little boxes made of tickytacky. They all look just the same." The PAPER included. Aesthetics. Quality. The excitement and thrill is gone from these hallowed pages.

I hunger for the way the PAPER used to be back in the "good old days" but with the "computer toys" of today and for godsake, don't lose that ad-man! Where was he five years ago? If we had ad-wo/men selling as many ads then, we wouldn't have lost so many talented people.

Keep The PAPER solvent, but make sure you save at least as much space for interesting and comprehensive coverage and photos or The PAPER will indeed become a "throwaway."

The good doctor-poet William Carlos Williams said, "it is difficult to get the news from poetry, but men die every day from lack of what is found there." Let's put the "poetry" and sparkling prose back into the
news so the audience doesn't die of malnutrition from a steady diet of milquetoast and boredom. Have I offended everybody yet? There seem to be feathers everywhere.

Yours in yellowed paparazzidom and Love,
Maureen Hurley
former Entertainment Editor, The Sonoma County Stump
former photojournalist, The PAPER

No comments: