ARE THE FRENCH REALLY RUDE?
Just back from spending the summer in South America, for me,
one of the first indulgences of coming home (besides marveling at flush
toilets, potable tap water and raw fruits and vegetables), is to read the Sunday
paper.
One title in This World section caught my eye. “Are the
French Really Rude?” Foreign LA Times correspondent Stanley Meisler writes,
“after five years in France, and American still has a puzzling time figuring
out the French. Are they really rude?
I read that article with particular interest because I was
going through the same dilemma after spending two months on the Gringo Trail
with them. In case you’re unfamiliar with the term, all those places we budget
travelers have been beating a path to, made popular in the “60’s, is the Gringo
Trail. Tropical beaches and ancient ruins are de riguer. Club Med is out.
One meets people from all over the world vagabonding on the
Gringo Trail but these days the bulk of travelers are comprised of young
Europeans. The trouble with the Gringo Trail is that the travelers tend to
bring to bring a portmanteau of their country’s obnoxious habits with them.
Friction develops.
Fellow tourists from other countries tend to get annoyed
with each other. Being forced to ride 14 hours in the Pullman car or a first
class bus with a group tour of rude Frenchmen is worse than water torture for
some travelers. I suppose a tour of North Americans or Germans would be equally
obnoxious— but one sees fewer North Americans on the road.
These reports
are not isolated instances of psychopathic travelers who have it in for the
French. For example, the journalist from Boston’s very first sentence to us was
to commiserate how rude the French were.
It seems one Frenchman didn’t like the way she moved his
suitcase in the overhead luggage rack above her seat to make room for hers. He
jumped up frothing and shoved her suitcase back screaming if he wanted his
suitcase moved, he would have done it himself.
Days later she’s still pissed off. The problem with the
Gringo Trail, is that you keep running into each other in various ruins and
cafes all over South America. Vendettas and quickie marriages are common.
There are times when I prefer a second class carriage with
its chickens, pigs and robbers to traveling with the French. When the train
stopped to wait for an oncoming train to pass, pity the poor traveler, unable
to face a second class pissior, who jumped off the parked train to take a quick
pee and lost his eyeglasses to a light-fingered Peruvian admirer in the
process. He was pissed off. P.O’d. is a more polite abbreviated term.
Any tree in a public park is well guttered with piss. A seal
rookery smells better than the local plaza. One rarely sees a Frenchman
traveling second class. I didn’t always have this racist attitude toward an
entire segment of fellow travelers. Being on the road with them too long did
it.
When I first came face to face with blatantly rude French
travelers was in Guatemala. It’s true they won’t give you the time of day. In
Latin America, every one graciously and politely greets each other. A greeting
is met with coldness by the French. Being in a restaurant with them can be embarrassing
for fellow Gringos. If they wanted to eat at Maxim’s why on earth did they come
here?
I though my normally liberal traveling companion’s bristling
tirade against the very sight of the French was a bit of an overreaction— he’s
logged many more miles than I have, with ten more years on the Gringo Trail than
I— I figured that they just pushed his buttons and the incident was merely one
of travelers crossing each other’s paths wrong.
That was until one Frenchman decided my bus window needed
closing with my hand still in it. I wasn’t upset that he knowingly slammed it
on my hand. He didn’t have the courtesy to ask to close it. As it turned out, I
was carsick— about to lose my cookies as they say— because he smoked a cigar
and I needed air. A minor brawl erupted. What thoughts go through their heads
that they prefer to do violence to fellow travelers than to speak anything abut
French?
Or the time one Frenchman took to shouting and laughing into
the wee hours in the open air bathroom adjacent to our room in a minus three
star hotel in the Galapagos. Minus star hotels generally don’t have glass in
the windows or curtains for starters. I asked him to be quiet in the lengua de
pais, Spanish, which he ignored. I tried both the formal usted and the familiar
tu forms. I even tried French. No luck.
It’s amazing how much English they do understand when it’s
delivered at top lung and peppered with stout anglo-saxon phrases. “Fuck” a
guaranteed attention grabber will usually trick them into speaking English with
you. Then they really hate you.
Next morning, he claimed innocence saying he didn’t
understand Spanish because he was French— as if that in itself was an excuse—
and proceeded to deliver insults like a schoolyard bully.
Lack of sleep does wonders for my Irish temper. He erred in
his judgment as to how much abuse I would take. Spineless, I’m not. Hell hath
no fury like a woman scorned. When he flicked his hand like a glove at my face
like a man about to challenge another to a duel, he got one.
I avoid physical conflict, being on the short side of small.
There was a time when I despaired that I would never reach five feet. That was
like breaking the sound barrier. When I was in 8th grade, the school bully, a
well developed “girl” named Tayde who outweighed me by100 pounds, and was a
foot taller, had me cornered and tormented me one time too many.
I went in swinging expecting to be killed on the spot but I
didn’t care any more. About the only place I could make contact was with her
boobs. We always speculated they were fake balloons. Well, they weren’t and
they didn’t pop. To my surprise, she laughed, and later became my friend.
I went for the Frenchman’s throat. I didn’t care that I was
creating an international scandal. I was out for blood. My companion separated
us and everyone thought he had pushed the Frenchman and jumped on him! Male
chauvinism. He didn’t become my friend.
I am reminded of the curious fact that the French installed
in their public buildings the placard, “no spitting and no Bretons allowed
here.” They have little love for the Celt yet they call themselves Gallic—
which is a Celt of course! The French, or the Franks of Charlemagne as they
were called, took what is now called France from the Celts in the first place.
It took the Bretons, last of the European Celts to rescind
the law concerning spitting and Celts. Llamas and Latin American men spit like
crazy. A disgusting habit. At least llama spit is mostly hay.
The natives get jaded fast from all this hobnobbing with
world travelers and demand money for everything from posing for photos to
tourists loitering in public squares and churches. Gone are the National
Geographic salad days of photographing the natives going about their business
in quaint settings with llamas gamboling about.
Kids are the worst. Dame plata, dame sucre. Gimme money,
gimme candy. And if you don’t give willingly to the cause, there are other
methods. They’ll come up and hug you, their tiny starfish hands thoroughly
frisking each pocket and wrist before you can say como te llamas.
They grow up to be razor artists who slash your daypacks and
pants pockets so everything falls out. There’s a funny story of a razor artist
so skilled that one unfortunate traveler’s pants fell off as he was walking
down the street. Some are that skilled. It gives new meaning to the word embarrassed.
In South America, one has to register name, age, nationality
and passport number at every tourist site and public transport. Each ticket
taker demands this information and woe to the traveler who resists. I assume
this precaution is in case there’s a coup so they’ll be able to identify the
bodies after. This does not make me feel any more secure.
Half the time, we weren’t about to list our passport numbers
namely because our passports were safely stashed inside a secret pocket in my
traveling companion’s pants which meant exposing himself in public just to get
the number and so we made up new ones on the spot.
Getting arrested for publicly unzipping and rummaging in
one’s pants in a foreign country didn’t appeal to us when there were so many other
more interesting things we could get arrested for— like false passport numbers.
Ticket takers are almost as irrational as the French when crossed.
My traveling companion, at 46, took a perverse delight in
noting he was usually the oldest person on the road. About the only time he was
upstaged was at Lake Titicaca by a 60-year-old New Zealand grandmother who
decided it was time to travel the world. So she left husband and kids to fend
for themselves for a year. At 12,600 feet, she did better than we did in the
thin air.
He said, admiringly, “I hope I’m in that good of shape at 60.”
My traveling companion and I were an anomaly. North Americans, Californians—
over twenty-three traveling with backpacks. Not many from our neck of the woods
travel in strife-torn Central and South America these days. The declining
dollar, the unofficial coin of the realm is keeping us home, but not the
Europeans who are able to travel at bargain prices. The median age of all the
world’s people is twenty-three.
The cliché that the French are rude as you’ve heard seems to
be true in Latin America. It’s become one of the topics of conversation in
coffee houses along the Gringo Trail. Latin Americans are complaining. Even
other Europeans. I’m not about to write off the entire French population. I
love French cooking. My aunt spent two years in Paris getting her Grand Diplome
at the Cordon Bleu School of Cooking. I can’t imagine the world without the
visions of Renoir, Cezanne or Debussy.
I also remember reading how the impressionist artists were
barred from the Salon of Painting because they did something different than
what was accepted as culture. According to my aunt the French come from a
stiff, unbending world, blamed in part on their rigorous school system which
focuses on rote learning rather than creativity.
“Shhhh! You Americans and French always at each other's
throats! France is a middling power, arrogant and with an inferiority complex,”
said a Limeño friend. It’s a pity so many take the national prejudices with
them.
I’m sure I will meet many lovely French people traveling. I
prefer the individual travelers to groups who may as well never have left their
native soil to begin with. Nationalism belongs at home.
I read that the French president Mitterand is one of the few
foreign leaders who stands up to the US and refuses to bow to its power and
influence. They have banned “American” words like hamburger and computer from
the French language, fearing the corruption of their language. Our language is
enriched by the addition of French. I can’t see North Americans boycotting
words like envelope, romance and intellectual because they’re French words.
I can imagine all the hate mail I’ll receive in French
envelopes on this one. (Oops, French envelopes means something else again.
Rubbers, galoshes).
One Peruvian
said France is too unyielding. It’s unable to bend. That is why it is no longer
a superpower. As Americans— let me digress. Calling ourselves Americans is
considered an imperialist attitude. And rightly so. It was pointed out to me
that North America also contained two other countries, Canada and Mexico. We
are all North Americans. English, Spanish and French.
Central and South Americans don’t call themselves Latin
Americans. They call themselves Americans! And they are also Americans. I’m
sure Kennedy addressing the people, “my fellow Americans…” had no idea he was
addressing two continents. Simón Bolívar’s dream was to unite South America and
call it the United States of South America. How different things might have
been if he’d succeeded.
As US citizens, we are often called on the carpet for our embarrassing
policies on Central America. We travel as ambassadors of the American people
who don’t necessarily support or agree with the political policies of our
nation.
Reagan is a very dirty word. Reagan may shoot down passenger
planes mistaking them for military planes in the Iranian Gulf but at least he
doesn’t go around blowing up Greenpeace ships protesting nuclear testing in the
South Pacific like the French did in Tahiti. That’s a very small consolation
prize.
I take it back. The man’s senile and crazy. Referring to the
destruction of Polynesia, Jacques Cousteau said, “small material things mask
the vital problems in the destruction of a culture. He was referring to his own
countrymen. Nationalist attitudes should stay at home with all the extra
baggage you don’t need (like the outboard motor) while traveling in a foreign country.
Stanley Meiser cites a stifling school system and foolish
posturing on the world stage as an excuse for their behavior. He writes, “all
studies show that outsiders look on the French as the coldest and least
welcoming people of Europe. They have no tolerance or time for spontaneity or
weakness.”
One begins to wonder why a group of people who steadfastly
refuse to learn the barest minimum of a foreign language would even want to
travel. Simple words like excuse me, con permisso, or thank you, gracias would
make all the difference in the world—well, not world but in the Americas at
least. ”When in Rome, do as the Romans do” obviously hasn’t yet been translated
into French.
The sad part is, aside from pissing everyone off, they miss so
much of the culture. Americans both the Latin and Northern of the species— are
gregarious and open. A Bolivian writer said, “Nowhere else in the world do
people treat you like the French if you do not speak their language.”
Note Bene: I transcribed these journal entries in 1988 - 1990, hence the variable dates. (I'm moving them all to 1988, journal entry date, not transcription/revision date). We were in South America during the summer of 1988. I was trying to publish these stories, or at least find a home for them. I've a vague recollection of the Machu Picchu piece being published in The Paper.
I was readying several of these Peru pieces pieces for an anthology, House on Via Gombito: Writing by North American Women Abroad. I also wrote Bill Truesdale, the editor for New RIvers Press, St. Paul, MN, a rather zany letter about my travels across the USSR. He took the letter, and not the stories.
After an incredible journey through South America, John Oliver Simon broke up with me, left me for a young blonde former student of his, and it took me nearly a decade to recover from the horror of it all. Going to the USSR in 1989 was my salvation—and still John was trying to reel me back in. Or maybe he was doing the AA thing, in his case, the SA 12-step thing, atoning for his wrongdoings. By that point, I wouldn't even give him the time of day. Ironically, we managed to heal the gap nearly 35 years later. So it's fitting that these pieces finally get to see daylight, after languishing in darkness for so long. —Maureen Hurley 2/26/2014
I've very few photos transcribed over to the electronic medium, another project. Here are three small albums.
Machu Picchu
Peru
Galapagos