What I don't like about Facebook posts: the plethora of Hallmark memes harping on our collective sentimental heartstrings, asking that we please post a photo of our dearest fathers for Father's Day. The assumptions made. Not all of us had a Leave it to Beaver upbringing. I would gladly post, if I had a father who was actually a father, rather than an absentee stranger who was an ardent supporter of the bar at Mission District's 3300 Club (which burnt down last night), and kept a chilled bottle of Seagram's in the ice box for when the bars were closed. When did it all go so terribly wrong for him? Before I was born. I found these photos after he had died. A life that I knew next to nothing about. No substitute father figure either. But a story of sorts emerged from the photos.
What I dislike are the Hallmark knee-jerk memes telling us how we're supposed to feel. Someone, I don't remember who, said to distrust sentimentality (as it led to fascism.). And, on some level, it's true as it creates an illusion, not a true emotion. Edward Abbey took it a step further with "Sentiment without action is the ruin of the soul."
Most of the fathers I saw growing up were also terribly flawed figures. So, I never sought out a father figure. It was a hard-drinking culture during the late 40s, early 50s. Mine left when I was four. He tried to connect a couple of times when I was 16, but by then, it was too late. His idea of taking his daughter out was to take me to bars. His usual haunts.
My father's mother did kill herself. Maybe that's where my father's wounding began... His father died soon after, of TB. He was a SF cop. They lived in Oakland, from what I can glean via birth certificates, then they moved to SF—by way of Boston, when, I don't know. I need to track that backstory down. A mysogenist uncle raised him. (Read into this, an alcoholic uncle?) It sounded like my father might have been better off as an orphan. He looks happy in the young photos.
What my mother's cousin said that he had a a terrible life, whoever was taking care of him was mean is spot on. I think my mom tried to explain his behavior with that story...meaning the uncle who raised him was a bit of a sadist. What saddens me is seeing the stories repeat themselves, generationally—certainly in my extended family.
The same holds true for my mother as well. I knew her well, but am glad she didn't raise me, it was always traumatic. She was manic-depressive. Her father was an alcoholic. All my aunts and uncles married alcoholics as well. My grannie was my salvation, she was both mother and father.
A friend made an interesting observation: "men have been massively victimized by the culture of machismo." And the "streetcorner virility-cripples club" an apt, and funny observation, that also conveys a lot of pain as well.
I found some family photos as we were cleaning out my grandmother's house. My mom's, and two of my aunt's photos (many in sad disrepair), as well as my grandmother's photos. This story emerged from the photos. I posted a memory from last year, that goes into greater depth, of the era of Big Band.
As to the stories that emerge, I am often the last to know how I feel, but by writing, I learn where I need to go. So far, I only had one pan dowdy making a comment about oversharing... I wanted to scream at him, You asshole! I am not seeking sympathy, I'm merely being a Sagge, saying it blunt, like it is... I guess that made Frank Toews uncomfortable. (I eventually unfriended him because of his constant derisive comments.)
I value everyone's stories, so often we sweep under the rug what must not be hidden. Other's stories, they enrich me, and I feel lucky to be able to share stories. Our perception and understanding of each other shifts. And empathy blossoms. we are all connected, I do feel the sadness, but I no longer dwell on it. It's like a tide that washes through me, not grief, but melancholy.
I also dislike how the world treated those of us who were parentless, sometimes as objects of pity, sometimes with derision, as if our unfortunate parental luck would rub off onto them. A shunning. When I confessed my mother was bipolar, the girls in high school literally excluded me, turned their backs on me, but they had the suburban life. They had no skills to comprehend what I was saying. This I learned much later in life."Nobody realizes that some people expend tremendous energy merely to be normal." —Albert Camus
I also dislike how the world treated those of us who were parentless, sometimes as objects of pity, sometimes with derision, as if our unfortunate parental luck would rub off onto them. A shunning. When I confessed my mother was bipolar, the girls in high school literally excluded me, turned their backs on me, but they had the suburban life. They had no skills to comprehend what I was saying. This I learned much later in life."Nobody realizes that some people expend tremendous energy merely to be normal." —Albert Camus
That history really doesn't run me, it's merely an old observation. But it also opens up dialogue with many people. so that's a good thing. Not catharsis, merely observation. It's really about the memes, how silly they are, and how everyone goes awwww.... What's really interesting to me is the developing dialogue in this thread.
And believe it or not, I did get a comment that gave me more information about my father...from my mother's cousin, I had no idea she even knew him. Something that would never have happened if I didn't post this Facebook thread. And I learned some backstory of others, things that I never knew about. Since I didn't know my father, it wasn't so much about repressed emotions, as a void... and many of the fathers I saw while growing up were also fairly flawed. So I was never a fan of Father's Day. My grannie was my mother, so that was less of an issue.
In the end, art was my salvation, what I turned to. (Well, my horse, too.) And later, to writing. Poetry saved me. Poetry was my mother and father.
Who was your father poet? My Father Poet is Pablo Neruda. Possibly WS Merwin, or Galway Kinnell as well.
from a Facebook post. See original thread here.
In the end, art was my salvation, what I turned to. (Well, my horse, too.) And later, to writing. Poetry saved me. Poetry was my mother and father.
Who was your father poet? My Father Poet is Pablo Neruda. Possibly WS Merwin, or Galway Kinnell as well.
from a Facebook post. See original thread here.













