Showing posts with label music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label music. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 2, 2023

Gordon Lightfoot’s Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald tune was from an Irish dirge



Yesterday, on Beltane, Gordon Lightfoot died. When I was writing an blogpost about Bobby Sand’s songs
Back Home in Derry, I took a lot of flack for saying that he did not steal or copy Gordon Lightfoot’s melody, Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald, because that old Irish tune already existed. Bobby Sands was in solitary confinement during the time he wrote that song, he would not have had access to Gordon Lightfoot’s ballad, but he certainly would have been familiar with the County Clare slide, most often used as a fiddle tune jig, The Road to Lisdoonvarna.

In several recent articles, I found that Lightfoot had acknowledged his use of the Irish tune. “I already had a melody in my mind and it was from an old Irish dirge that I heard when I was about three and a half years old.” Why couldn’t I find that information back in 2013 when I was writing the Bobby Sands story?

Finally, I found a quote from Gordon that supports my theory. I wish I had found this quote when I was writing my blog post, Old Tunes, New Licks. It would’ve saved me a lot of grief. I wrote:
The melody of Canadian folksinger Gordon Lightfoot's The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald, recorded in December 1975, seems to suggest a similar pattern. What came first, Lightfoot's melody of The Wreck of the Edmund FG, or the Irish melody associated with Bobby Sands' Back Home in Derry?
I think what happened is that the melody itself (not Gordon's fabulous song lyrics) was based on an older Irish dirge—after all the ship had an Irish name, Fitzgerald, so an Irish melody was fitting. Also, many Canadian folksongs are from the Irish and Scottish folksong repetoire.
During the 1960s and 70s folksingers were raiding traditional music wholesale—Irish music was the hardest hit—most North American singer-songwriters did not credit their sources. At least two of my folk heroes Judy Collins and Joan Baez noted their folksongs as "traditional," but as Behan noted, Bob Dylan was among the most arrogant of songthieves.

The Lightfoot obituary went on to say: 

“The biggest came in 1976 after he [Lightfoot] read an article in Newsweek about the the sinking of the bulk carrier SS Edmund Fitzgerald on Lake Superior on November 10, 1975. He called the epic maritime disaster song, “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald.”

“It was quite an undertaking to do that. I went and bought all of the old newspapers, got everything in chronological order, and went ahead and did it because I already had a melody in my mind and it was from an old Irish dirge that I heard when I was about three and a half years old….I think it was one of the first pieces of music that registered to me as being a piece of music.” From Gordon Lightfoot, Canadian Folk-Rock Troubadour, Dead at 84 , Yahoo

After I wrote this piece, I found out from Mudcat the name of the Irish fiddle jig was The Road to Lisdoonvarna. Old melody. Full circle. Someone else said that Christy Moore set the poem to music, not Bobby Sands. Now that is ann angle I have not thought of as I understood it to be Bobby Sands’ melody as well. All the Google links suggest that Christy Moore borrowed Gordon Lightfoot’s tune. Egad! Circular file. Either way, it was an Irish tune shared across the sea. RIP Gordon Lightfoot. Safe passage.

Sunday, May 1, 2022

RIP Naomi Judd

Note bene: I never know where my next writing idea will come from, where it will go, or what spawns an idea, usually it’s because of a Facebook post that serves as a trigger, I write a comment which leads to another comment, and so on. I never expected to be floored by the death of Naomi Judd, someone I didn’t even know. But there you have it. It seems Facebook style Wakes are becoming a thing. This is a developing piece based on a lot of hear-say (stet) as I only knew her on on the periphery. Call it 1° of separation if you must. So bear with me as I uncover a West Marin story.

A new Facebook friend, activist Sandra Birnhak, who grew up with Diane/Naomi in Kentucky, said she went by the name Naomi back in the late 1950s, early 1960s, so maybe she changed her name back to her given name, Diane when she was in LA, with her then husband, Michael Ciminella, before moving to Lagunitas. She was only 17 or 18  when she had her first daughter, Christine, in 1964. 

Sounds like Hollywood wasn’t kind to her—in her autobiography, River of Time, she mentions about being molested by an uncle, she abandoned by her husband, then, at 22, she was raped by an ex-con heroin addict. I don’t know how she wound up in the San Geronimo Valley, but it was a haven of single mothers. Since I only knew of her peripherally, I’m still piecing together the stories… 

Backstory: The Judds once lived in Speck McAuliff’s apartments above the post office in Lagunitas (where I once lived as a young child before my parents split up). Then they moved up the road to north a cottage on Tamal Road next to the House of Richard (a hippie store), and they also lived on Resaca Avenue as well.  

Tuesday, December 1, 2020

UNCHARTED JOURNEY, 8 freewrites to music by Kirk Whipple and Marilyn Morales


1. Light

Perhaps the idea of light began with Morse code. 
An SOS from deep space. My mind wanders 
to the opening bars of Chief Inspector Morse. 
Who doesn’t love puzzling out a good mystery?
Yet the truth of the flute 
had other destinations in mind.
I am reminded that I am not in charge. 
The mind maps of music, 
each is unique. A signature.
A frenzied rhythm, the hummingbird of war.
The coda is another message, a cypher
and then the piano brings it all home with an arpeggio. 
A cascade of music ends with the one-note song 
of a car horn on distant streets, 
reminding me of old Havana, 
a place where I’ve never been, 
a place where I can never return to.
And I mourn for what was lost.
And for that was coming.

2. Morning Zephyr

The sea breeze is a sister to the wind chimes. 
Someone once told me the wind was sighing, 
or perhaps there were angels hidden in the eaves.
A sophisticated melody reminds me 
that the piano is a harp on its side 
and I think of the ancient Greeks 
leaving Aeolian harps on stone walls for the gods
so that the wind would have an accompanist,
so that it was not alone. Yet the music of the wind 
in the pines is as a primal roar akin to fire, 
and we combust as we listen to the wind 
playing the old notes that resonate deep within the psyche. 
And that flute. I envision a girl in an alpine meadow 
keeping company with the wind. There is no other lover 
other than time. An old woman sits 
beneath the casuarina trees 
dreaming of distant shores,
and other beachheads.

3. Quiet Thoughts

Starlit music, wavering lights from distant galaxies 
lifts us to the sky glittering with arpeggios of hope. 
It is as if the moon were slipping 
off her beaded flapper dress 
onto the silk cloak of the sea 
and look how she lies back, 
odalisque moon low on the horizon. 
She is the same moon reflecting 
in the mirrors of barway doors and brothel halls.
When we look up, for a moment we might forget 
the ordinary and the mundane, but her journey 
is effortless across the distant seas. 
The moon, a siren dancing in her own wake.

But fairytales always have a twist. 
No, not Disney versions all sanitized 
with the scary bits expunged. Real fairy tales
where fear is palpable, and devours us.
Water can’t find its way back to the sea 
on a level playing field. We can’t find our way.
We need the elevation to bring us down 
to the shore from such lofty heights 
to the sea, the sea, the shining sea 
fanning its lace fan on the shore 
waiting for the last dance.

4. Our Dance

The rhumba of morning flashes onto the sea, 
so still, after the eclipse. Your eyes take in 
the opalescent thunderclouds. Storm out to sea,
and yellow morning light bathes the city. 
A pulsing glow verging on tangerine 
fades into pale gracenotes. Coral atolls, 
the sophisticated dreams of tropical fish 
painting the water with their bodies. 
Small dancers of kinetic art. 
I am most at home when I am in the sea.
The clouds come down to drink from the horizon 
gathering up all that light. 
The distance of time, the tango, 
and the ticking of an old clock in another room, 
a relentless metronome. We are every age all at once,
we are both young and infirm. Art saves us.
The soft rain on the sea, the sweet tears of joy 
falling from nascent clouds.

5. The Blue Path

Snazzy snap and step of the dancer, 
the jazzy path and tickle of piano. 
Blue notes, late nightclubs of the soul 
loitering after hours, the sleaze of cigarette smoke,
a chorus of martini glasses, or is it mojitos at dawn? 
Breakfast of champions. Well, for Hemingway 
it was, of course. Poor man offed himself for no real reason. 
It was either writer’s block, or he was too drunk 
to stand at the typewriter. The sun also rises, 
the sun is a rose, old man, and the sea is opalescent, 
the meniscus beckons, old man. The sea. A boat.
The staccato of a drum solo, surely Africa is invoked.
I want to tell Ernest to wait it out, the best is yet to come. 
That sullen, relentless art. We’ve all been there. 
We dance across the darkness of the dance floor 
snapping our fingers, we are dancing 
like moths towards that burning light.

6. Little Glass Houses

Small birds in the eaves take flight 
and weave the air into a gossamer gown 
made of webs. Transparent thought. 
A hungry sun begins its journey 
and the birds sing a crescendo. 
They are at the center of it all. 
The windows of the soul and all that. 
I think of Cadiz, a place I’ve never been. 
Wind chimes dream another melody into being.
The birds dip and weave, collecting the last notes 
and feeding them to their young.
Their pinfeathers are almost all in. 
Soon they will be ready to fledge, 
taking strands of the melody with them 
wherever they go. They will pollinate the air 
with their relentless songs.

7. Joy

He is running through the forest on a dirt track, 
he knows the rhythm of the heart, 
the pounding of his feet on the pine loam, 
the vague order of vanilla underfoot. 
A place of solace, a retreat, annealed by fire. 
He is taking down to the bass notes, 
that of rock and loam and sky. 
The dreams of trees released in smoke 
with only the sky to witness their last will and testament. 
The uncharted journey of burned needles 
settling back down to earth, miles from home 
in the form of emberfire, 
a combustion of the soul, annealed by flame, 
and the final song of trees.

8. Tributaries

Water over stones, the song of boulders.
The journey to the sea begins in the mountains 
as snow and rain. Thunder, hail, 
and then the melody begins to emerge 
from the crevices of rocks, 
at first, so small, like the twinned breath of birds and wings. 
Then it deepens, it grows in timbre, circling 
each waterworn course with the finesse of a dancer, 
gaining momentum with each passing. 
The river is a gateway to the sea, and a chorus awaits, 
it seeks an audience with the wind 
and then the rocks are ground into pebbles, becoming sand 
while the waves play them against the shore.

Freewrites from Uncharted Journey, 1986
You can listen to Joy here.

Tuesday, May 15, 2018

Carnyxes on my mind


Imagine a Roman legionary encamped in enemy territory, awakening to the otherworldly Gallic sounds of war. As myriad carnyx tongues flutter eerily in the predawn mist, you are reminded of the saying, The enemy of your enemy is my friend. Visiting UC Berkeley scholar, musicologist Simon O Dwyer made a replica carnyx and when he played it for us, my hackles rose. I tried to play it, they're hinged, on a pivot, mid-point, and are exceedingly heavy. You need serious upper body strength to carry and play them. The sine curve is well balanced. Let's just say I lost my balance and went careening off into the walls, for a mad Monty Python moment, but I managed to not crash the instrument. Pretty much. Any composure I might have had was lost. The looks on their faces, their mouths and eyes, silent white Os. I always meant to transcribe my notes but got hopelessly lost, they were so convoluted.

A video where musician John Kenny demonstrates a Celtic carnyx. You can also see Celtic warriors playing  the carnyxes on the Gundestrup cauldron. And on this rare Celtic gold coin that depicts both a chariot and carnyx.



"Fig. 2 Gold quarter stater of Ambiani tribe. On one side is the head of Apollo with a lyre hidden in his curly hair. On the other we see a Celtic hammer-god driving his chariot across the sky. He has long flowing hair and holds a large hammer in his right hand. He may be Sucellos ‘the good striker’. A big bee – the Celts made mead with honey – buzzes before the horse’s snout. Only one other specimen of this coin is known and that is in the Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris. The above coin will be sold by auction early in March." The link is dead.

See my story 

Wednesday, December 21, 2005

FIRST FREEWRITE TO KIRK WHIPPLE on 5s project A E F W & Q

FIRST FREEWRITE TO KIRK    ramblings that wouldn't separate themselves into orderly piles of air earth fire and water let alone, transcendence

In the beginning was verb
fire danced on water
myriad fireflies etched traces of fire and starlight

in the bayou    crossing the bog
where at water's edge
live coals
sang a reptilian siren call
it's an eat be eaten world
and on it goes

Friday, November 21, 2003

Dancing to Clifton Chenier at the Cotati Cabaret

Some 25 years ago I was dancing with Clifton Chenier’s son Julian, who was a long way from the bayou. Bon ton roulet, he said, let the good times roll. And we danced a hot Cajun style under the harvest moon during the break. We all stood in constellations under the oak trees, admiring the spin that only a cold, clear night can put on the stars, and the beauty stained the retina for a moment, we forgot ourselves and gazed rapturously at those pinpricks of light. But in the shadows, a drunk leaving the parking lot, blinded us with his headlights, and we were thrown into the small cages of self walled against the night. Unfortunately the drunk was also taking another car with him, doggie bumper style, and then I realized it was my poor VW bug being dragged through the gravel like a recalcitrant donkey. I ran down the parking lot after the drunk, screaming, but he kept driving with my car in tow. Just as I got up to him, he disengaged and took off down the road. I was screaming like a banshee, and Julian was holding me back, saying it’s cool, it’s OK, let it roll. Let it roll right off your back. Come on back inside and dance dance Cajun style with me—and with that he climbed up the stage steps and played a lick on his guitar. Soon we were all dancing dancing in a sea of kelp arms, reaching for the disco ball, myriad stars dancing on our bare shoulders, dancing, dancing, dancing. 

11/21/2003 Writers’ Group

Tuesday, March 19, 2002

Prehistoric Irish music notes with Simon O'Dwyer


Galway musician Simon O'Dwyer opened his lecture by drumming on a bodhran. He said that the bodhran is a musical instrument virtually unchanged since the Stone Age. We all coo. Then he throws a wrench in it: asks, or was it introduced in the 19th century?

No matter, Irish drumming is unique. The hand is used as a swing, not as a slap, like with a tambourine, and the circular unique beat is like a metronome with orchestration, or grace notes with thematic variations—which makes it one of the most complex drums in the world.
which in turn, suggests great antiquity. Not a modern invention. The idea is old. He talked about how some of the stones at Stonehenge if struck, sounded like a drum.

He introduced a copy of some Bronze Age silver pipes found in 1927, which are considered to be the oldest instrument made of metal in the world. They look like a tin-penny whistle. Or, rather, two penny-whistles as they’re played simultaneously, like panpipes; one was a drone with four holes and the other has three holes. Its sound was very much like a bagpipe tuned to E flat—similar to Sardinian music.

Then Simon showed us his cast Bronze Age horn replicas, from circa 1150 BC to 600 BC. He speculated that two volcanic eruptions: one in Iceland, and another in Japan, created a 20-year winter, where there was minimal growth during that time, and then he asked, did the twinned catastrophes cause a change in society? Increased warfare?

Simon explained that there was an explosion of weaponry, and huge fortifications burst upon the scene, so it was probably a period of extreme poverty, and starvation in Western Europe. There were also suddenly lots of horns on the cultural horizon—the largest single collection is in Denmark, and northern Germany had rich sites as well, replete with casting techniques so fine, we can't reproduce them today.

Simon mentioned working with colleague Peter Holmes, a former Rolls Royce mechanic, who became an aircraft engineer and geophysicist, took up the trumpet and turned into a music archaeologist. Peter is considered one of the world's leading experts on ancient lip-blown instruments. His Brass for Beginners is a groundbreaking classic. With his background in engineering, Peter was able to recreate ancient musical instruments literally from the ground up.

Simon said the Celtic horns were made in a two-part mold, held together by chaplets, then cast, with walls 2 mm thick, which means they are very thin. It was on the cutting edge of technology that focused on the rituals of war-making versus weaponry. All the support sciences were cutting edge as well. You needed charcoal and tin. Tin mining was documented in northeast Ireland—especially in Antrim. 

The first remanufactured Celtic horn Simon showed us was the first Celtic war horn played in Dingle at a parade, in 3000 years, and it sounded like a didgeridoo. It was similar to horns made 3000 years ago. He decided to make a new one, a replica,. “I made a new one to wake it up again,” and said, it's such a unique sound, Listen! And then he demonstrated it. It made the hairs on my arms stand on end.

Simon said that the Celtic horn design was a unique concept in Europe, yet it's similar to the horns of Africa. The didgeridoo wasn’t even introduced to Africa until 1965. According to Seán Ó Riorda, the two notes were used as a carrier, like a drone, and the mouth was used to change the sound.

The voice of the Celtic horn is very much like a conch sound, it uses vocce and overtones—like the circular breathing techniques of the Tuva people of Mongolia who also use circular breathing. They use voice-generated notes to split frequencies and create overtones—sometimes called a chorus of angels—resonating within your body, as well as within the diaphragm. Your body becomes a pump; in essence, a bagpipe, and you can pulse it too. You use your hands to alternate notes, to create harmonic change, and then there are pedal notes and bwerm notes. He blows raspberries. We laugh.

Horns are always found in pairs: One sideblow, one endblow, like cast cow horns, but more complex with a hyper aperature curve—a so-called invention of the 1800s—like french horns, but with more complex shapes, it creates certain harmonics attractive to the ear.

A question was raised were they battle instruments, or sacred instruments, or were they used for music—a more religious aspect, or meditative aspect. 

Simon answered, In County Offaly, 26 horns were found, bells and cockles, a handbell that looked like a grenade, so it indicates religion or ceremonial aspects.

Not only England, but also Scotland also has sideblow horns, he shows us a drawing of one from Sussex. He said, In Ireland, it's at least a 9500-year-old tradition. Large horns from Kerry were found, but with no mouthpieces that survived. He speculated that perhaps they were destroyed to protect the instrument from being played again—like Irish pipes?

Because no mouth pipes survived into the modern age, Simon O'Dwyer had to invent an actual working mouthpiece, he played with many different types before he came up with one similar to an aboriginal tradition that still living as there is no living tradition within Ireland for the rhythm section or Bronze Age horns.

Simon launches into a story, In Tulsk, there is an ogham inscription about Ailil mac Medb in Rathcroghan, County Roscommon, about the Cruachán and the Cave of the Cats, Uaimh na gCat which is a vaulted cave where the three-headed cat lived. The portal to the Otherworld opens and the Morrígan emerges on Samhain. He said, this is from an older racial memory More than 3000 years old, which was visited by Celtic Ireland at the end of the Bronze Age. He said, we know this because suddenly the designs are different with the introduction of new ideas including Iron Age swords. This was the first use of sheet bronze which arrived with new technology, including the use of riveting, from circa 500 BC to the pre-Christian era.

In 400 BC, the Etruscans used sheet bronze to make horns, there are two surviving Horns in the British Museum. Peter Holmes compared these Etruscan horns to the Irish horns which are more finely made musical instruments. The Etruscan ones by comparison are crude, and made by craftsmen vs. artisans.

The evolvement of the horns in Ireland was not interrupted by invading Romans. The horns were probably introduced to Tuscany from Helvetia, or Celtic Switzerland. The trumpet-like trombone had a thousand rivets within ribs to hide them. The question was was it a circle, a half-circle, or was it like an S shape like the horns of Nepal? We don't know—it can go either way but of course, no record of it survives. It only survived in pieces so we don't know if it's like a carynx with a boar's head.

The Romans wrote of the Celts leading the armies into battle with their horns. Cuchulain in the Táin Bó Cuailgne, used Bronze Age horns derived from cowhorns, these fragments survived within the tale. Cattle wealth culture. The trumpets from this era. Four were found in a loch, and at Evan Mahha circa 60 BC, they were recovered in 1798. Three were lost, buried in Argyle, Scotland (this bit’s garbled, sorry. I couldn’t keep up with Simon).

The head of plate on the trumpet is done in repoussé style, it's called the Lotus design. There’s speculation that it's a design from the Middle East. The plate is a loudspeaker, it vibrates at a certain frequency, the wave links out can be heard, it's omnidirectional. The Ailill horn, like the one depicted on the Gundestrup Cauldron, played so beautifully, that soldiers died of rapture.

The shockwave wave pattern compresses and carries a couple of miles. A loud war parade would have a lot of fanfare and a trumpet craobh, there’s one in Dublin, not on display, about 8 feet long with artificial lips. A copy was made, computerized in Edinburg University.

An trumpa fada, the long trumpet had 1024 rivets. Only one rivet was missing, and it was 2000 years old. It was longer and heavier and was used on the ground, it was orchestral vs an instrument of war.

Another horn was found in Loch Erne, it was made of yew and bronze, and sounded like a full Gregorian chant.

The Mayophone was found in 1795, some 9 feet under in a bog in County Mayo, hence the name. The Mayophone looks like it was a double-reed instrument and it was made of willow which produced a softer sound. Possibly the earliest bassoon-chom family instrument in the world, it was 6 1/2 feet long, and the two halves of yew were carved out and bound together with bronze.

This is the first one it's ever been shown, or and even played. The next one will be up made of bog yew. It’s like a cornet it needs to be long to get those 17 notes. It’s the only example of a double reed instrument in the world. All the instruments were tuned into a common pitch: either G, C, low E, A, it had perfect pitch or tone. Africa has many similar instruments.

We got a chance to examine the instruments he played, and we even tried our hand—or lips 
—to get a feel for them. I had a slight mishap with the longhorn as it was much heavier than it looked. It took me for a little sleigh ride, as I careened around the room beneath its weight, scaring both Simon and the audience. I was so embarrassed but also delighted to have attempted to play such an instrument.


Any errors in this transcript are solely mine, I was madly taking notes on something of which I knew nothing about, and I have little knowledge of wind instruments. My notes were nearly illegible and I despaired of ever transcribing this to an electronic format. There’s probably lots of articles that are more comprehensive, and more clearly written, but this was from a private lecture arranged by Dan Melia, and it was cutting edge scholarship for the time. Please visit Simon’s site to get it direct from the horse’s lips.

Monday, November 14, 1983

Little John Chrisley. NEED TO ADD PIX & STORY

Little John Chrisley was an up-and-coming blues harmonica player, a child prodigy who played with all the greats, and then he disappeared. I did a story on him at the Sonoma County fair. For the West Sonoma County paper. Need tear sheet and pix






Whatever Happened to Little John Chrisley? 1/20/1998 metro publishing

Friday, September 24, 1982

Russian River Jazz Fest, Adam Makowicz interview



Top Polish pianist's escape to the home of jazz
BY MAUREEN HURLEY

At the Russian River Jazz '82 music festival, world-renowned Polish pianist Adam Makowicz made his  Sonoma County debut to an enthusiastic audience of nearly 1000 Sept. 12. Billed for the past five years as Europe's number one jazz pianist, and chosen by America's jazz bible Downbeat international critics poll in 1979, Makowicz is making huge inroads on American audiences coast to coast and the Jazz '82 audience was no exception.

A recent emigreé to the United States, Czechoslovakian-born Makowicz lives with his wife in New York. He describes himself as a country boy used to open spaces and villages living in the middle of Manhattan. He emigrated to the US from Poland nearly five years ago because, the wholesome-looking, blond haired pianist said with a twinkle in his blue eyes, "America is the home of Jazz!"